by Carolyn Barrett, Proprietor, Pleasant Valley Kitchen Company, LLC
I did not create the original recipe. A pub owner in Rochester, NY served chicken wings with a similar sauce at his establishment. I offered to help him bring the sauce to market. I knew it would sell well because there isn't anything available on store shelves that is anything like it.
Although he was not interested in marketing the sauce beyond his pub, he did share the ingredients and measurements. Even with the recipe, I was not able to re-create the sauce. It seemed like there was some critical element missing, and I wondered if that was the pub owner’s way of keeping his recipe a secret.
I had been buying it from him for several years when, sadly, he died. I knew then I could not let the recipe die. Something this delicious and unique deserved to be brought to the public. I actually feel like I am performing a public service, bringing it to market.
It took me four months and about $400 in wasted ingredients to figure out the recipe. There were many discouraging times when I thought I would never figure it out. But one of my mottos is, if you try hard and it still doesn’t work, it means you have to try differently. And that’s exactly what I did until the secret of the sauce revealed itself to me.
After my husband built me a commercial kitchen in our home, I started selling the sauce in July 2008. Originally named Sticky Fingers Gourmet Sweet Sauce, the product name was changed to Sugar & Spice Sweet Sauce to avoid trademark infringement.
By popular demand, the product no longer contains high fructose corn syrup (effective April 2009).
WATCH TV10 INTERVIEW, DECEMBER 29, 2009: (it takes a moment to load)
Grilled chicken breasts/pork chops,
seafood/vegetables
Fried chops/chicken/wings/fingers/nuggets
Baby back ribs
Fried shrimp/scallops/seafood
Bacon wrapped scallops/shrimp
Tempura
Chinese/Asian take out/egg rolls
sushi
plain cooked broccoli
anything you want to sweeten or spice, such as salad dressings, tomato based sauces, stir fry, rice, oatmeal, etc.